2
$\begingroup$

I'm a New Yorker and take the subways every day. I have a growing interest in understanding the distribution of paths people take on the subways to work every day.

I.e. if there are $n$ subway stations, I want a temporal distribution over the paths $\omega = (n_i, n_j, t)$ where $n_i$ and $n_j$ are nodes representing subway stations and $t$ is a continuous variable representing time.

I am given the expected arrival and departure times for each subway station as well as the number of people who enter and exit each station at discrete moments in time.

I am hoping someone can give me ideas on how to translate my deterministic model into one I can fit statistically, as well as reason about theoretically

Ideal Theoretical Model

Let $N$ be the total population in the subways at any given moment in time and let $N_i$ be the number of individuals in station $i$, and $N_ij$ be the number of individuals on the subway line heading from station $i$ to station $j$. The total number of individuals in transit $$T = \sum{N_{ij}}$$

and the total number of individuals in standby is $$S = \sum{N_i}$$

Then $$N = T+S$$

I have 1.5 undergrad physics classes under my belt so I've been thinking about the system with the following analogy. Imagine the subway station to be a system of $n$ point masses(each point mass is a subway station) suspended in space, where $N_i$ represents the height of each point mass.

Each adjacent subway station exerts a downwards and upwards force on its neighbors. In particular $F_{ij}$ is the force exerted by $i$ on $j$ such that $$F_{ij} = g(N_{ij})$$ where $g$ is some unknown function.

In this light, the net force on station $i$ is defined as

$$F_{\text{net}, i} = \sum{ F_{ji} } - \sum{ F_{ij} }$$

In other words, at each moment in time, every station exerts a force on its neighbors. Actually, to be more precise, this force based model implies there are actually $n^2+n$ particles between stations and $n$ stations, therefore a total of $n^2 + 2n$ particles. The velocity of a particle is the rate at which its height decreases and the mass of a particle is a coefficient $m_{ij}$.

Having interpreted the subway station as a group of point particles with pairwise interactions under an unknown force mechanic, we can also define a potential energy configuration.

$U(N)$ defines the potential energy configuration of the system and $U_{ij}(N)$ defines the potential energy of a particle $ij$, such that

$$U(T(t)) + K(S(t)) = E(t)$$

$$K_{ij} = \frac{1}{2}m_{ij}v_{ij}^2$$

$$U_{ij} = -\int^{N_{ij}}_{0}{F_{ij}} = -N_{ij}m_{ij}$$

Fluctuations in $T$ and $S$ represent changes in the internal potential and kinetic energies of the system. Fluctuations in $N$ represents net work being done on the system, i.e.

$$W = \Delta E$$

Issues in the Model

I still haven't defined $g$, nor defined the potential and kinetic energy functions.

Statistical Modelling and my Question

At this point, I have a cute little physical interpretation of the subway system. But I am having trouble translating my dynamical model into one I can statistically fit to find a distribution over the ultimate paths taken by individuals over the course of a day.

  • In practice, I don't know what "modelling the subway dynamics" will actually mean?
  • Ought I to fit coefficients to $g$ , $U$, and $K$?
  • How to formulate a rigorous statistical question given this abstract physical model.

Or

  • Alternative ways of finding the distribtion of trips, including links to literature that has already solved this problem.
$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Probably there is a better solution but alternatively you can try cellular automata approach. I saw many papers about modeling of similar phenomena using such an technique. $\endgroup$ – Krzysztof Bzowski Feb 14 '17 at 12:52

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.